Little Mix vs The Saturdays

Little Mix vs The Saturdays

  • Total voters
    39
ZenGiraffe

ZenGiraffe

Who is SHE though?
Pronouns
He/Him
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
23,989
Location
San Marino
Since both of their megamixes are in the Moopy Zeitgeist, let's settle this question (despite the answer being OBVIOUS)



 
The Saturdays have higher highs, but I’m more likely to put on a Little Mix album than a Saturdays album
 
I wouldn't sit through an album by either, but that Satz singles run is beyond reproach. Little Mix have had their moments but those have all got Jesy Nelson croaking all over them to their detriment.

Honorary mention to impeccable babe Jade Thirwall who wins the overall Best Band Member award.
 
I think I’m going to vote Little Mix. Before Confetti, I would have said Saturdays, but their newest album and 600 random singles have been really great and pushed it over the edge
 
RJN said:
I think I’m going to vote Little Mix. Before Confetti, I would have said Saturdays, but their newest album and 600 random singles have been really great and pushed it over the edge
Click to expand...
THERE'S ALWAYS ONE...
 
My kneejerk reaction is to vote Little Mix, but I feel I need a single by single comparison in the interest of fairness.
 
Little Mix by a country mile. The Satz were candy floss, Little Mix are an M&Ms Selection Box.
 
Little Mix always seemed a lot more fun 4 five year old girls.
 
It's a tough one. I was more switched on to pop when The Saturdays were active. A lot of Little Mix's stuff passed me by. They both had high highs and a lot of filler. Neither can quite compete with the iconic run of Eternal - Spice - All Saints - Sugababes - Girls Aloud in British girl group pop history.
 
I always felt too old for Little Mix whereas the Saturdays’ pop seemed to cross a wider age range and I enjoyed it more so I voted them. However, as in the previous post the mid 90s to early 00s run of big names where far preferable (to me).
 
Cannonball vs If This Is Love
Wings vs Up
DNA vs Issues (meh to both though)
Change Your Life vs Just Can't Get Enough
How Ya Doin'? vs Work
Move vs Forever Is Over
Little Me vs Ego
Word Up vs Missing You
Salute vs Higher
Black Magic vs Notorious
Love Me Like You vs All Fired Up
Secret Love Song vs My Heart Takes Over
Hair vs 30 Days
Shout Out to My Ex vs What About Us
Touch vs Gentleman
No More Sad Songs vs Disco Love
Power vs Not Giving Up
Reggaetón Lento vs What Are you Waiting For
Only You
Woman Like Me
Think About Us
Bounce Back
Break Up Song
Holiday
Sweet Melody
No Time for Tears
Confetti
Heartbreak Anthem
Kiss My (Uh-oh)
Love (Sweet Love)
No

Little Mix have a lot more singles, but it was 12-5 Saturdays... this is tough. I do know neither will ever compare to Girls Aloud or Sugababes for me
 
(I say this as if Black Magic isn't one of my favourite LM songs. But it isn't a patch on Notorious)
 
Since I haven't done this enough formats already...

1. Ego (Saturdays)
2. Up (Saturdays)
3. Move (Little Mix)
4. 30 Days (Saturdays)
5. Not Giving Up (Saturdays)
6. Holiday (Little Mix)
7. Higher (Saturdays)
8. Touch (Little Mix)
9. Sweet Melody (Little Mix)
10. Salute (Little Mix)
 
RJN said:
Since I haven't done this enough formats already...

1. Ego (Saturdays)
2. Up (Saturdays)
3. Move (Little Mix)
4. 30 Days (Saturdays)
5. Not Giving Up (Saturdays)
6. Holiday (Little Mix)
7. Higher (Saturdays)
8. Touch (Little Mix)
9. Sweet Melody (Little Mix)
10. Salute (Little Mix)
Click to expand...
And at what point will you be correcting your poll vote then?
 
Iguana said:
I am listening to the Right Back At Ya podcast about The Saturdays (sorry @dUb) and the hosts hated Missing You and it upset me.
Click to expand...
Oh I love that podcast, babe. It’s all love in the gay pop culture podcast community. (There’s one I hate actually but mustn’t dwell.)
 
Cannonball vs If This Is Love
Wings vs Up
DNA vs Issues
Change Your Life vs Just Can't Get Enough
How Ya Doin'? vs Work
Move vs Forever Is Over
Little Me vs Ego
Word Up vs Missing You
Salute vs Higher
Black Magic vs Notorious
Love Me Like You vs All Fired Up
Secret Love Song vs My Heart Takes Over
Hair vs 30 Days
Shout Out to My Ex vs What About Us
Touch vs Gentleman
No More Sad Songs vs Disco Love
Power vs Not Giving Up
Reggaetón Lento vs What Are you Waiting For --> ?
 
Beverley said:
Cannonball vs If This Is Love
Wings vs Up
DNA vs Issues
Change Your Life vs Just Can't Get Enough
How Ya Doin'? vs Work
Move vs Forever Is Over
Little Me vs Ego
Word Up vs Missing You
Salute vs Higher
Black Magic vs Notorious
Love Me Like You vs All Fired Up
Secret Love Song vs My Heart Takes Over
Hair vs 30 Days
Shout Out to My Ex vs What About Us
Touch vs Gentleman
No More Sad Songs vs Disco Love
Power vs Not Giving Up
Reggaetón Lento vs What Are you Waiting For --> ?
Click to expand...
Marsha threw the first brick for this!?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top Bottom