FetchFugly
Pregnant
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2005
- Messages
- 26,506
Rose Matafeo is with us on Alexander.
I meant has a shield holder ever attempted to have been murdered and been shielded successfully though? Not sure it has...There's kinda been loads of successful shields, because normally when they reveal to the group they have it, it works as a deterrent anyway.
I see your point, but of the secret shields...?There's kinda been loads of successful shields, because normally when they reveal to the group they have it, it works as a deterrent anyway.
I meant has a shield holder ever attempted to have been murdered and been shielded successfully though? Not sure it has...
Leanne won't keep Alexander around - think it'll be just her & Jake
Wouldn’t you try and get one more out so you’re not having to split the money three ways? It’s a risk continuing the game, but less of a risk if you’re the only one to vote for it as why would a traitor want to keep playing?I'm just not sure once they've already got rid of 2.
If they know the rules they'd know it would have been an ultimatum so he wouldn't have lived to tell the tale.
I think she's set on the idea that Alexander isn't to be trustedI'm just not sure once they've already got rid of 2.
Wouldn’t you try and get one more out so you’re not having to split the money three ways? It’s a risk continuing the game, but less of a risk if you’re the only one to vote for it as why would a traitor want to keep playing?
I thought he meant that Leanne had chosen to recruit instead of murder & was using the shield to pretend that didn't happenSpeaking of the rules - it annoyed me Alexander put the theory out that Leanne is a traitor and “murdered herself” because she had the shield. I think it’s been established by now that traitors can’t murder traitors (regardless of shields) so that theory should have been shot down.
I think, especially now that people have seen the show and seen traitors win, no one will ever vote to end early again. Series 1 it only happened because the game was unfamiliar to the players and Wilf basically gave away that the three left were faithful.
I don't think so at all, especially given how things are just so stacked against the faithful without it. Charlotte and the traitors will lose much more as a consequence of her disloyalty than this twist. Fucking over both Minah and Freddie is much more consequential. If Freddie hadn't voted for her on the way out, she'd at least have a chance of convincing people that Frankie is lying. And if he hadn't been banished at all, or Minah was still around, then the traitors would have two against three, meaning they'd just need to convince one faithful to back them to win the final night (and then have to convince that same faithful to turn on the other traitor to get a solo traitor victory)This twist is also incredibly unfair, and has clearly just been thrown in to provide a faithful win.
Charlotte fucked herself over, but she at least had a chance before this twist. Now she has no chance (although judging by the level of stupidity seen in this game before, who knows).I don't think so at all, especially given how things are just so stacked against the faithful without it. Charlotte and the traitors will lose much more as a consequence of her disloyalty than this twist. Fucking over both Minah and Freddie is much more consequential. If Freddie hadn't voted for her on the way out, she'd at least have a chance of convincing people that Frankie is lying. And if he hadn't been banished at all, or Minah was still around, then the traitors would have two against three, meaning they'd just need to convince one faithful to back them to win the final night (and then have to convince that same faithful to turn on the other traitor to get a solo traitor victory)
Again, because Charlotte chose to be the only traitor in the final. We'll likely see next year the traitors be a little less willing to go into the final alone. Which I would argue has always been the ideal move, but greed takes over too quickly.It’s also similarly unfair in that if Frankie had chosen a faithful to meet, they could just vote their way to the end in an almost guaranteed win (because clearly everyone trusts Frankie is a faithful at this point).
Breakfast > Challenge > Lunch/Dinner > Round Table > Endgame is pretty much guaranteed. The only unknown is whether they all meet up again after the reveal before going to sleep, but there won't be a traitors turret, so my guess is they will go straight to bed after dinner without conferring and breakfast is the first chance Frankie will get to talk to the othersJust seen speculation that Charlotte could attempt to spin Freddie's vote for her as him protecting Francesca as the other traitor, which is an interesting take.
What is the timescale for all this happening, in terms of Charlotte being able to formulate a plan after meeting with Francesca? Is there another night, or does play resume straight afterwards?
And look at how she repaid himJust want to say when Alexander had said he hoped Francesca would be the Seer so she can find out he’s a faithful was just lovely![]()
What other fun parts of the game would you like to create rules against, cwej?