Favourite compilation album

[Suedehead]

I've included remix albums in this but have excluded EPs.

 

[RJN]

Celebration has the most hits, but it doesn't have Deeper and Deeper OR Human Nature, which is unforgivable

 

[octophone]

I've still never listened to disc 3 of Finally Enough Love.

 

[octophone]

This poll proves we still need a proper singles compilation - no fucking about, no 12" versions just all the 7" mixes on 3 or 4 CDs. The first 2 CDs of that would be imperial, the third and fourth at least interesting.

 

[Ellie]

While obviously The Immaculate Collection was iconic, and actually my first proper introduction in to Madonna (I remember Like a Prayer coming out but too young for everything before). Now I prefer most of the album versions, and the omission of Who's The Girl and True Blue was just odd. Something To Remember kind of came out of nowhere and is a very well curated themed compilation rather than just an attempt at a comprehensive singles collection.

 

[VV]

The Immaculate Collection should have been the best, but it missed out too much good stuff - and the versions used were inferior to the original single versions.

Plus, it had Justify my love, which is terrible.

 

[funky]

The Immaculate Collection should have been the best, but it missed out too much good stuff - and the versions used were inferior to the original single versions.

Plus, it had Justify my love, which is terrible.

People have been locked up for saying less