Finally caught up with this. Despite quite a few dogshit elements, I can't give it less than an 8 because I enjoyed it a lot, and for a film on its 6th outing almost 30 years later, with so many crucial elements still intact (Gale, Sidney alive, the fact it's still got a BUDGET!) we can't really ask for more. Halloween could never etc. Scream has managed to retain its identity in a way no other franchise quite possibly ever has.
I agree the reveal was SHIT, and nonsensical. I mean, that's kind of Scream tradition, pretty much only the first film and arguably the fourth for HIGH CAMP reasons have decent reveals, but this one just didn't give a fuck if it made sense
As said, as if they wouldn't all have known....
I was sort of hooked by the opening because of new Scream excitement, but it was dreadful really. Definitely one of the worst parts of the new era.
And despite still not giving a shit about the new characters, at least they had time to breathe in this film. The last one didn't work at all - we were supposed to invest in the original three and a whole new (badly fleshed out) bunch, where's the ROOM? This gave them more of a chance to shine but it's still hard to care. I don't know why - it's not like the original cast were necessarily fleshed out, but somehow everyone, Tatum, Randy, Stu, never mind Sid/Dewey/Gale, even Drew's role, all felt like proper characters. Maybe it was the quality of the actors, or the fact they made everyone quite cartoon-like except Sidney (which then made you root for her) and gave them all a chance to stand out. They're just a bit too wall papery this era.
However, I do actually love Sam's back story with her dad. I love they keep leaning into it, and they did a decent job of making you uncertain of her through most of the film.
And finally, I thought Gale's moment was phenomenal and up there with some of the best Ghostface scenes in the series. It was dragged out just enough and seriously kept you on edge and guessing until the end. It's still got it