The Israel-Gaza War (1 Viewer)

ButterTart

ButterTart

Succulent Chinese meal
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
58,049
Location
The Land of Broken Dreams
Following a request from posters in the original Israel-Gaza topic, the modmin team have decided to create a new thread to continue the discussion. The original thread will still be viewable but is no longer open to new posts.

This is an important topic and it's essential to have this outlet for everyone to have their say, but when the conversation becomes too heated it ceases to be productive and puts those involved in danger of posting something which does not do them, their beliefs or their character any justice.

Going forwards, the modmin team feels it's important to make a couple of things clear.

1. Moopy does not support, condone or seek to justify the loss of innocent lives on either side of this conflict, and we will take action against any post which contradicts this stance.

2. We will not tolerate antisemitism or islamophobia anywhere on this website. This should go without saying.

3. If you're concerned about the content of a post in this (or any) thread, PLEASE report it. Even if you feel like you just need a judgement call on whether it's acceptable or you think the wording needs to be amended, report it. Every report is anonymous and we will address each one.

4. If you're posting something from social media, please check your sources. Consider who the content creator is and whether posting it will contribute positively to the discussion in the thread.

This is a contentious subject which, naturally, carries a lot of emotional weight for all of us. We want everyone to feel able to contribute their voice to the conversation, and for that conversation to remain civil, factual and productive.

The modmin team may suspend a poster from replying to this thread at any time pending investigation, and violations of our community guidelines may result in a warning, or even a temporary/permanent ban from the website.

If you need clarification on decisions made by the mod team in this, or any other thread, we encourage you to speak to us in the Forum Forum. We aim to be as transparent and even-handed as possible with all moderation across Moopy.
 
IMG_4071.jpeg


With great power comes great responsibility

Anyhow, back to the endless murder of Palestinians
 
Anyway my favorite piece of propaganda from the last 2 days

 
More than anything, I would just like a thread where we can bear witness to the immense suffering that is being waged against the Palestinian people, using weapons funded by our taxes. I don’t want to get into fights or political discussions about who did what to whom and who is right and who is wrong. I just want to bear witness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: COB
I'm finding it hard to know which news source has the most validity. I've been getting a lot from Al Jazeera but keen for recommendations.

It's all so horribly and blatantly corrupt.
 
The families of the hostages have been so brave throughout this, many speaking out in favour of a ceasefire and humanitarian solutions, and they've been absolutely demonised by the right wing of Israeli politics and media - it's shameful :(
 
Rowan Tree 🌳 said:
I'm finding it hard to know which news source has the most validity. I've been getting a lot from Al Jazeera but keen for recommendations.

It's all so horribly and blatantly corrupt.
Click to expand...

Al Jazeera is/was the only news agency with reporters inside Gaza, so even though I found a lot of the images they’ve shown too difficult to watch, I’ve given it a little more credence than the Western channels who didn’t go in, choosing instead to go on IOF led tours and repeating IOF propaganda points. Follow me on Twitter - I’m trying to read whatever I can find from people I trust on there.
 
COB said:
The families of the hostages have been so brave throughout this, many speaking out in favour of a ceasefire and humanitarian solutions, and they've been absolutely demonised by the right wing of Israeli politics and media - it's shameful :(
Click to expand...

They are a light in all this. I’m finding their ‘everyone for everyone’ call for hostage exchanges so moving and powerful. Yes, there are 200+ Hamas hostages, but over 10,000 Palestinians unfairly detained by Israeli forces. The cruelty, whomever it is by, has to stop.
 
Something we could all do in the UK atm is write to our MP and pressure them to vote for ceasefire when it is brought to Parliament on Wednesday.
 
The crackdown on protestors and anti Israeli statements in Europe is also getting scary. Just 2 recent examples



 
  • Sad
Reactions: COB
And another thread showing how most of our governments understand that Israel is deliberately inflicting as much chaos, death and suffering as possible:

 
COB said:
The families of the hostages have been so brave throughout this, many speaking out in favour of a ceasefire and humanitarian solutions, and they've been absolutely demonised by the right wing of Israeli politics and media - it's shameful :(
Click to expand...


I appreciated this
 
Some things we could maybe think about:

- a lot of Israeli and Western leaders (eg even Grant Schapps) are using the bombing of Dresden or Hiroshima and Nagasaki as parallel justifications for the bombing of Gaza, but these things were war crimes. International law was developed as a mechanism to prevent the scale of wanton destruction that these attacks wreaked on those places.

- Al-Shifa Hospital was precisely attacked because it was the hospital responsible for identifying and recording the civilian casualties in Gaza. Since the bombing of the hospital, casualty figures have not been updated for three consecutive days. The numbers and images that have come out of Gaza have horrified so many of us into action. That is what Israel is trying to stop.

- On the subject of figures, whilst the US has poured doubt on the numbers coming out of Gaza, and western journalists taken to discussing the ‘Hamas-controlled’ ministry of Health, US department of state cables have relied on the figures from this ministry for YEARS. Israeli tv is using the same statistics. One Israeli source even suggested that the death toll could be twice what is coming from Gaza.
 
I’m consistently torn between ignoring this thread for the sake of my mental health and forcing myself to stay educated on how horrible and infuriating it is. Besides, my stress of reading about it is nothing compared to the people experiencing it.

The propaganda though. I’ve never seen such depths of desperation. Imagine seeing this unfold and your instinct is to put all your energy into defending the Israeli government by any means necessary.
 
Beverley said:
- Al-Shifa Hospital was precisely attacked because it was the hospital responsible for identifying and recording the civilian casualties in Gaza. Since the bombing of the hospital, casualty figures have not been updated for three consecutive days. The numbers and images that have come out of Gaza have horrified so many of us into action. That is what Israel is trying to stop.
Click to expand...

according to Amnesty, al-Shifa hospital has been used by Hamas as a base to torture and murder Palestinians for over a decade.


F-zuYXNWkAECqwC
 
Last edited:
That's terrible, but it's also the largest hospital in Gaza and now it's been rendered all but useless which will lead to even more death.
 
joanne said:
according to Amnesty, al-Shifa hospital has been used by Hamas as a base to torture and murder Palestinians for over a decade.


F-zuYXNWkAECqwC
Click to expand...

Yup I’ve seen that, but it doesn’t disqualify what I’ve said. Nor does just it justify the bombardment or ground operation that is currently going through.

It’s worth noting that Israel have had control of Al-Shifa for the last 18+ hours and still haven’t produced evidence to justify their actions. On the contrary, it’s quite convenient that when it was time for them to takeover the hospital, the White House suddenly produced intelligence claiming the Hamas command centre was in the tunnels - the only underground area beneath the hospital, allegedly, is one that Israel produced when it controlled Gaza in the 80s.
 
Last edited:
And it seems that what Amnesty is saying is quite different to Israel’s claims (a disused outpatient unit used to torture vs underground tunnels being the command centre), no?
 
Beverley said:
Yup I’ve seen that, but it doesn’t disqualify what I’ve said. Nor does just it justify the bombardment or ground operation that is currently going through.
Click to expand...

i didn't claim it justifies the bombardment. but to say that Israel bombed the hospital "because it was the hospital responsible for identifying and recording the civilian casualties" is quite misleading since Israel has been transparent about their intent of bombing all Hamas bases since the war began. Al-Shifa hospital is a target because it's a Hamas base, not because Israelis are trying to manipulate numbers like you implied.
 
joanne said:
i didn't claim it justifies the bombardment. but to say that Israel bombed the hospital "because it was the hospital responsible for identifying and recording the civilian casualties" is quite misleading since Israel has been transparent about their intent of bombing all Hamas bases since the war began. Al-Shifa hospital is a target because it's a Hamas base, not because Israelis are trying to manipulate numbers like you implied.
Click to expand...

Debating this is a distraction for me, so I don’t want to, but allow me to restate that there is a reason why western sources have poured doubt on the numbers coming out of Gaza, and there is a reason why we are no longer getting those numbers anymore. If you think the Israeli government is not interested in the PR aspect of this conflict, so be it, but that is my assessment, and the assessment of countless more experienced figures.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top Bottom